Review: 1Dollarscan Book Scanning Service

I often review books and games on the site, but this is the first time I reviewed a service. Specifically, the book scanning service offered by 1dollarscan.com. 1dollarscan will scan any text item (books, photos, business cards. etc) and then use optical character recognition to convert the images to searchable text.  I have some reference books with no PDF version available for digital searching purposes and decided to convert one of them as a test of the service.

I decided to risk my well-thumbed copy of  “The Encyclopedia of Occultism.” I chose it because it is far more useful as a searchable digital book and I did not want to lug it around. It weighs a ton!   That and I could replace it easily for little money online if my little experiment failed and the book went down a black hole. 1dollarscan charges $1.00 per one-hundred pages scanned. The encyclopedia is just over 400 pages, so I rounded up and paid $5.00 to 1dollarscan, plus another $5.00 for packaging and shipping via media mail to California.  Off my book flew…

Two weeks pass and I just received an email with a download link to a 480 Mb PDF file. I downloaded it and it was my book, digitized and OCR’d. Here are a couple of pages from the book.

 

 

Fear the Illuminati…

 

Scans are crisp and very readable. The downside is the file is 480 megabytes! I may compress it to make loading and browsing faster.

The OCR is adequate, but not amazing. All OCR requires human editing and for $1.00 per hundred pages, I doubt any of that went on with my file.  Here is a sample. The first is an image of a paragraph and then the OCR’d text version is just below.

 

 

ftromrnoy : Divination by m9an9 of cheese.. .It is practised

in diveis ways the details of which are not known’

 

 

In defense of 1dollarscan, I did send an old book with a darker background and a tight font. I knew the OCR would suffer, but thought it a good test.  This about as bad as the OCR got, many of the other entries are completely readable. Still, the book is more searchable and lighter than it was to begin with and at $10.00 I am not going to complain too loudly about the end result. Besides, the scans are clean enough that if the OCR search gets me close to what I am looking for I can just use the old-fashioned method.

Oh, the cover does not get scanned either. This is a bit odd, but it did not really bother me as the contents mattered more than the awful circa 1962 cover design. It was hideous!

As for the other issue hanging over this post, let me get it out of the way now. Here, I will say it for you because you are probably thinking it. “Pirate!”  “You are stealing the hard work of the author, etc, etc, etc.”  Not at all. I owned the book. I had the book converted to a new format for my personal, fair use. I will not distribute it beyond my own digital library. In addition, 1dollarscan DESTROYS the books it scans. Be very clear on this issue. Cards, papers and images can be returned if you ask (and pay for it). Do not send in first editions or that signed copy of the DMG. It is sacrificed to the automated book scanning god.

There is an old saying, “You can have something good, fast and cheap, but you can only choose two.” In this case I scored 2.5 of the three items. 1dollarscan is dirt cheap, very fast and the outcome was pretty good. If anyone else runs something through the service, drop me a comment. I would like to hear how it goes.

 

Trask, The Last Tyromancer

 

 

 

 

 

6 Shares

trask

Trask is a long-time gamer, world traveler and history buff. He hopes that his scribblings will both inform and advance gaming as a hobby.

4 thoughts on “Review: 1Dollarscan Book Scanning Service

  • September 7, 2011 at 4:27 pm
    Permalink

    Dear Trask

    Thank you for the great post and thank you for using 1dollarscan.com

    We will continue to improve our quality of service and keep you updated on future announcements.

    Frank

  • September 7, 2011 at 5:47 pm
    Permalink

    1917 Wednesday, 07 September 2011

    I will send 1dollarcan.com more books to scan.

    1dollarscan provided high-resolution full-color scans of every book I
    sent, including the front covers. (You can overcome this with human
    proofreading or a well-trained program.) The resulting PDFs have large file sizes. Storage costs little these days, and you can shrink them with a little effort and thought.

    I’ve scanned many of my own books, and I can do a better job than
    1dollarscan. It takes much longer to scan a book by hand than it does
    to earn the money to pay for 1dollarscan’s service.

    Piracy disclaimer:
    I scan books for my own archive. I call this fair use. I am not a lawyer, but if any of the authors whose work I scanned wish to complain–good luck. I intentionally chose works by long-dead writers. If Sophocles really wants to sue me, fine. I’ll get in line behind all the other people who want to talk with him.

  • September 19, 2011 at 6:18 pm
    Permalink

    A question answered nowhere on the 1dollarscan website:

    Is 100 pages 100 sheets, or 50 sheets?

    If my book ends on page 192, do I pay $2? Or do I have to count the title page, table of contents, and preface numbered in Roman numerals?

  • September 19, 2011 at 6:35 pm
    Permalink

    My book was around 450 numbered pages, so I rounded up to 500. That did the trick. Does not look like they do units smaller than a dollar.

    Trask

Comments are closed.