Palladium Books v. Trion Worlds Rifts Trademark Dispute–The Court Ruled…
In the ongoing saga that is the Palladium Books v. Trions Worlds trademark dispute, there is a major development. Over the past few days several motions appeared before the court, covering everything 
from outright dismissal for lack of jurisdiction from Trion to requests for discovery and restraining orders from Palladium. All of which took place at a very rapid pace over the past week. Today, the court finally issued its ruling regarding the motions and I am a bit surprised.
In short, the court dismissed the complaint filed by Palladium.
The full filing is below, but here is the important bit.
For the reasons stated above, the Court grants Trion’s motion to dismiss under Fed. R.Civ. P. 12(b)(2) for lack of personal jurisdiction. In addition, the Court denies Palladium’s request for expedited discovery. Finally, Palladium’s motion for a preliminary injunction is denied for lack of personal jurisdiction.
I will save you some time and just say the court did not rule on the trademark issue at all. The reason for the dismissal was a lack of jurisdiction by the Michigan court. The motion for discovery and the injunction for the E3 trade show were also denied. That said, I wonder if Palladium will re-file in a California court, where there is no doubt about jurisdiction over Trion.
Here is the full document.
Palladium Books v. Trion Worlds Decision
I will keep you apprised, as always.
A special thank you to Jason at the “Jason Richards Cannot Be Trusted” blog for the use of his clever logo.
Trask, The Last Tyromancer
About the Author: Trask is a long-time gamer, world traveler and history buff. He hopes that his scribblings will both inform and advance gaming as a hobby.
Man, bummer for Palladium. Big time. I saw a lot of ways for this to go down, but I didn’t think the jurisdiction thing would bit them. Well, that shows what I know. :) Guess I’d better write a reaction piece now.
Glad you dig the logo!
I wonder how many Michigan residents attend E3? Did the court consider that? THAT would be substantial contact, wouldn’t it?
/Sub
[...] Kevin writes about the battle it faces to win its trademark suit, citing the deep pockets of its opponent. And he’s not kidding: Trion Worlds’ investors include Time Warner, NBC Universal, Bertelsmann, Rustic Canyon Partners, Trinity Ventures, and DCM, with HP as a strategic partner. As source reports, PB has not succeeded in getting the suit over and done with quickly, which does not bode well. (source) [...]
[...] Recent Comments Subjugator on Trion Worlds Responds to the Palladium Books “Rift: Planes of Telara” Trademark Lawsuit–Comes Out Swinging!Lilth Ann on Trion Worlds Responds to the Palladium Books “Rift: Planes of Telara” Trademark Lawsuit–Comes Out Swinging!Kutark on Trion Worlds Responds to the Palladium Books “Rift: Planes of Telara” Trademark Lawsuit–Comes Out Swinging!Sybert1138 on Trion Worlds Responds to the Palladium Books “Rift: Planes of Telara” Trademark Lawsuit–Comes Out Swinging! Palladium Books Embroiled in Another Crisis by Purple Pawn on Palladium Books v. Trion Worlds Rifts Trademark Dispute–The Court Ruled… [...]